Skip to content Skip to footer
Civil | Mainville v. De Santis Rentals. LLC
A Case for Justice

This page shares the journey of my legal battle that began as a simple complaint filed with the Attorney General's office and evolved over a year into a federal civil rights case against judicial officials in District Court, Court of Appeals, and the Office of Administrative Hearings working alongside opposing counsel and my previous landlord. As of August 2025, the complaint includes 39 claims of constitutional violations. I haven't been able to name all the parties in my complaint because the NC Court of Appeals refuses to release the names of the judges who ruled on the alleged violations.

There is a timeline below where you can click on each of the events and view the documents associated with it. The documents have not been altered other than to remove emails, phone numbers, certificates of service (unless they pertain to an argument), my medical history, signatures, logos, and repeated emails in replies. On some documents, I've added direct notes to clarify the record, while others speak for themselves.

I have been representing myself in these proceedings, which has presented its own challenges and opened my eyes to the fact that what we perceive as a fair and impartial tribunal is in reality very subjective. I have contacted multiple channels for answers and support and continue to face deflection or am straight up ignored, as you will see below. I will try to update this site and respond to any messages as quickly as I can.

NOTE: Nothing on this page constitutes legal advice. These are my personal experiences, positions, and filings related to my case only. If you're facing a legal issue, please consult with a licensed attorney. You can also check out the resource page that has links to some sites that offer legal advice.

Lady Justice

A Call for Action

Call for Action

Sign the petition demanding a non-partisan investigation into the North Carolina court system and support critical reform to restore transparency, accountability, and fairness in our courts.

Timeline of Events

Below is the timeline of events based on my judicial logs, with the most recent event at the top. I’ve compiled everything so you can see just how much I’ve had to manage on my own while working full time. You can use the filter options below to view entries based on your preference.

I’ll do my best to keep this updated, but as things continue to progress, the federal court increases the burden it places on me while revoking fair access for electronic filing without just cause. This requires me to take over 2 hours just to file in person during working hours or pay printing and mailing fees if I can’t take time off from work.

I also have a full timeline log on Google Sheets that I compiled to help stay organized, which will remain up to date and you can view any of the cases online through the court and Pacer RECAP.

*For some reason, my OAH contested case doesn’t show up on the public filings, which is case number 25HRC00824.

Reference of Filters:

  • Civil Dispute: The overall civil case
  • Court of Appeals: Actions or filings at the NC Court of Appeals.
  • Court Order / Judgment: Rulings or orders issued by a court.
  • Defendants: Events specifically involving De Santis Rentals, Anna De Santis, or her counsel
  • DOJ / AG Office: Events involving the Department of Justice or NC Attorney General’s Office.
  • Federal Court: Events or filings at the federal court level.
  • Judicial Misconduct Alleged: Allegations of serious judicial misconduct or abuse of judicial authority.
  • Law / Statute / Information: A state or federal law, rule, or case law cited or tips pertaining to the event.
  • NCHRC / HUD: Actions, delays, or issues involving the NC Human Relations Commission or HUD.
  • Office of Administrative Hearings: Events or filings within the NC Office of Administrative Hearings process.
  • Plaintiff: Events, filings, or actions initiated by me as the plaintiff.
  • State Court: Events occurring in Small Claims or District Court in NC.
  • Violations: Clear, provable breaches of law, rules, or tenant protections committed by defendants.
  • Attorney Misconduct Alleged: Ethical or procedural violations committed by opposing counsel (Frank McGraw & David Yopp).
District Court | Plaintiff
Appealed to District Court
I filed my Notice of Appeal and Amended Complaint, adding a third claim for defamation while keeping the core allegations of breach of contract and unfair trade practices the same.
Dec 16 2024
complaint | NCHRC
More NCHRC Delays
Despite the 90- and 100-day deadlines passing without notice, I had to follow up twice before hearing back, only to be asked for information I had already provided.
Dec 12 2024
District Court | Court-Ordered Arbitration
Arbitration Hearing
On November 13, the hearing was conducted and I was award nothing despite undisputed evidence.
Nov 13 2024
complaint | NCHRC
NCHRC Interview & Response
After two more weeks of going back and forth, the Investigator finally scheduled an interview. I also received the evidence Anna submitted with the same false narrative.
Nov 4-12 2024
complaint | NCHRC
Contacting Director of NCHRC
Contact the director after the investigator still wouldn't reach out. Internal communication shows why she didn't take it seriously.
Nov 2-4 2024
Email | De Santis Rentals LLC | Attorney Frank McGraw
Evidence of Defamation
Notifying Frank that I received evidence of the reference and defamation.
Nov 1 2024
complaint | NCHRC
Contacting Manager of NCHRC
After waiting a month to have investigator assigned to my case, it took another month before I even heard from her.
Oct 1-23 2024
POST SMALL CLAIMS | Plaintiff | Chief District Court Judge Margaret Eagles
Motion for Leave
The complaint I filed against the magistrate and the lack of accountability.
Aug 26 2024
District Court | AOC
Court-Ordered Arbitration
I received notice the court assigned court-ordered arbitration to my case.
Sep 10 2024
POST SMALL CLAIMS | Plaintiff
Small Claims Appeal
Requested a jury trial due to what happened with the magistrate
Sep 3 2024
Email | De Santis Rentals LLC | Attorney Frank McGraw
Final Communication
Final communication with Anna explaining the impact her behavior had on me and why I would hold her accountable.
Sep 1 2024
Email | De Santis Rentals LLC | Attorney Frank McGraw
Vacating the Premises
The magistrate allowed an improper motion, accepted hearsay without evidence, and showed personal bias. Despite clear evidence, my claim was denied, and I was scolded and denied a full opportunity to defend myself.
Aug 27 2024
SMALL CLAIMS | HEARING | MAGISTRATE KURT WILLEMS
Small Claims Hearing
The magistrate allowed an improper motion, accepted hearsay without evidence, and showed personal bias. Despite clear evidence, my claim was denied, and I was scolded and denied a full opportunity to defend myself.
Aug 26 2024
SMALL CLAIMS | PLAINTIFF (Me)
Amended Complaint V2 & Outline of Events
Updated the rent abatement and loss of work amounts and provided court with supplemental documentation.
Aug 24 2024
SMALL CLAIMS | PLAINTIFF (Me)
Response & Amended Complaint
Notified the court of the improper filing and refiled my complaint with full details and events.
Aug 21 2024
SMALL CLAIMS | Defendants | Attorney Frank McGraw
(First) Motion to Dismiss
Improper Filing that violates NC GS 7A-216 and often used to intimidate pro se litigants.
Aug 19 2024
Complaint | Raleigh City Code Enforcement
Warranty of Habitability Violations Found
Summary of the Code Enforcement complaint, the clear evidence of fraud by the landlord, and how gaslighting and misrepresentation expanded into deliberate, malicious conduct.
Aug 9-23 2024
Complaint | NCHRC | HUD
Discrimination & Retaliation Complaint Filed
Filing of my discrimination and retaliation complaint with the NCHRC & HUD with a breakdown of what discrimination means in this context.
Aug 5-16 2024
Email | De Santis Rentals LLC | Attorney Frank McGraw | Myself
Evidence to Retaliation
Cease and desist emails where Anna made misleading statements about my tenancy then her and her attorney engaged in extensive gaslighting to avoid responsibility or correction of her actions blocking the opportunity for a home.
Aug 5 2024
Complaint | DOJ/AG
Consumer Complaint Second Findings
AG’s mishandling of case, improper acceptance of false claims, and how my warning about press involvement was later used by the DOJ to unfairly prejudice a separate case.
Aug 2 2024
1 3 4 5 6